[US] Recommend USB HDD enclosures (1 or 2 bay)

Off Topic
1

Very off topic of course.

My media server is small (~8TB) so I can fit it all on a single HDD. I'm looking for recommendations for a USB enclosure that would work the best with a NUC-like miniPC I already have. Must be at least 5Gbps port (USB A preferred but USB C is fine). 2-bay is fine (as long as serial numbers/SMART are reported well to Ubuntu), so I can using snapraid for some parity.

I've tried a couple from Amazon (Yottamaster 2 bay for eg) and heat has been a bit issue - they don't have any fans. So I'm looking for a decent solution that I can use 24/7.

@Animosity022 curious what you use for your 20TB staging drive.

2

I use a 4 bay personally with a System76 machine miniPC.

Amazon.com: Mediasonic USB 3.2 4 Bay 3.5” SATA Hard Drive Enclosure – USB 3.2 Gen 2 10Gbps Type C | USB-C (HF7-SU31C) Support 18TB HDD : Electronics

1 Like
3

Nice. Mind saying more about your setup (with the software)? I've yottamaster and orico enclosures and they seem to mess up serial numbers which makes everything quite challenging.

4

I don't really do anything special. Fedora Linux, few drives and rclone.

1 Like
5

Got it. The reviews on that unit seem to also call out terrible heat dissipation so I'll assume you have the door off.

6

Nope. In my basement and no heat issues.

7

Okay I just got the probox (HF2-SU3S3) and so far it seems just like other enclosures I've tried. SMART works just fine, however fdisk -l and by-id don't show the serial numbers (2 drives in my case):

usb-ST8000VN_004-2M2101_152D00539000-0:0
usb-ST8000VN_004-2M2101_152D00539000-0:1
usb-ST8000VN_004-2M2101_152D00539000-0:1-part1

$ sudo fdisk -l | grep -i Model
Disk model: 004-2M2101
Disk model: 004-2M2101

This means disks won't have stable identifiers (moving them from one bay to another can cause issues). I believe this can be mostly worked around by setting disk labels during formatting. More testing is needed though.

The other bad thing about it is that after a power outage, the enclosure doesn't automatically turn on. I have sync disabled (I'm okay with it being always on) but even with enabling it, I wish it would automatically turn on.

Will do more testing.